Free Our Data: the blog

A Guardian Technology campaign for free public access to data about the UK and its citizens


Show Us A Better Way winner: Can I Recycle It?

The overall winner of the government’s Show Us A Better Way competition is Can I Recycle It, which (inter alia) “will tell people what the recycling facilities are in their area, based on their postcode.”

Congratulations to Adam Temple, 26, from London. He explained his project to the Cabinet Office, which awarded his prize: “Each area has a different recycling scheme with different capabilities, so it is not surprising that households are unsure what can be recycled. Local information may be of some use, but there are a million and one things that people want to know about recycling.

“Having put in their postcode, the householder will get an easy-to-read version of what is recyclable and what is not in their area. After that, they could type in keywords for the specific piece of rubbish that they are concerned about. If it is in the database, the householder would get an immediate answer.

“If not, the question could be forwarded to the appropriate person in the local council. That person could then amend the database, and that way the website would gradually get more useful.”

(I’ll vouch for it: my local council only recycles plastics 1, 2 and 3 – though actually what would really help would be if manufacturers of packaging were obliged to print in large diagrams which of the many recyclable plastics theirs were. It gets kind of boring holding packaging up to a 100W light to try to discern whether the number two millimetres high inside the recycling logo is a 3, 5 or 6.)

Show Us A Better Way attracted more than 450 entries from around the world, with around 70,000 people visiting the website over the summer. The total prize fund was worth £80,000.

Cabinet Office minister Tom Watson, who spearheaded the competition, said (to quote the Cabinet Office press release):

“This is a world-leading competition that has attracted entries and praise from as far away as Australia, India and the USA. Show Us A Better Way has really captured the imagination of people in their own communities. This is about taking service design out of Whitehall and to the people who use it.

“By trusting the public and throwing it open to them to put forward their ideas, the solutions are of real, practical use. Ultimately, this is about building something from the bottom up rather than having Whitehall dictate from the centre.”

Watson also said: “This ingenious idea is a simple map showing you where recycling facilities are and what they will accept, so you can quickly and easily find out where to take your rubbish.”

And there’s even a quote from Hazel Blears, who we hadn’t noticed being entirely in favour of these bottom-up things recently: “The positive response to this competition rightly highlights the power and benefits when local people have their say, have access to good information and have the enthusiasm and the chance to make a difference locally. I am pleased that extra funding from CLG will help take some of these creative ideas forward and help encourage the use of new technologies and community media. Access to information – which these awards aim to promote – is an important part of empowering communities.”

Michael Wills – who has been an important driver of more open access from within the Ministry of Justice, and who would have helped raise prizemoney for the competition – said: ““The Government is committed to encouraging people to get involved in civic activities within their communities and across the country. Show Us A Better Way highlights the innovative ways in which people can do this.”

Just as important, SUABW seems to have inspired a similar project in the US – where there’s now a competition called Apps for Democracy running in Washington, DC, soon to be the home of that Obama fellow – who might have some people on his staff who will take note. Only $20,000 prizemoney, but it’s a start.

And congratulations to everyone again who entered SUABW – it has inspired a lot of thought within government about what can and could be done with data once it’s made available.

7 Responses to “Show Us A Better Way winner: Can I Recycle It?”

  1. Gerv Says:

    As comments on the post on the Guardian website indicate, this seems to already exist at http://www.recyclenow.com/ … Does that mean you need to re-award the prize?

  2. Tom Page Says:

    Yes – I’ve used http://www.recyclenow.com many times – I don’t understand how this project is any different!

  3. DMN Says:

    I thought about recycle now when I heard about this award – and my own councils website too:

    http://www.brighton-hove.gov.uk/index.cfm?request=b1000037

    It seems like a waste to have awarded this prize to a duplicate service when some of the other ideas were uniquely useful. Hey ho its only public money…

  4. Gary Says:

    Agreed. Some of the “winning” entries were poorly researched. “Where’s my nearest post box” can’t work either because the Royal Mail refuse to disclose that data and claim they don’t keep exact locations on file. Some weight should have been given to the registered public votes and comments made when it was put to the public to pick a shortlist of winners. Granted the anonymous votes couldn’t be trusted but the registered votes and comments should not have been so readily disregarded.

  5. paul canning Says:

    This has been dropped.

    From Public Sector Forums:

    PSF’s added value: We can today exclusively report the planned ‘Can I Recycle It’ website has now – for want of a better phrase – been dumped.

    In a supreme example of common sense winning the day, the Government now plans to use the prize fund cash to work with Recycle Now to raise its public profile.

    The Cabinet Office told PSF today the competition judges had been unaware RecycleNow existed, despite having looked ‘long and hard’ for similar initiatives.

    “Searches for similar ideas did not throw up any similar sites and nobody mentioned it in the comments section of SUABW”, said a spokesperson.

    “The Power of Information Review was very clear about not duplicating sites so we won’t be building a whole new one”, they added. “The competition was always about ideas, and this is an idea that visitors and judges agreed had legs. As it was already out there we’ll be working with them to make it more successful, providing the service the person who suggested the idea wanted.”

    The current plan is expected to include search engine optimisation, such as making Recycle Now more prominent in Google search results, given the judges couldn’t find it in the first place. Thus, needless duplication has been avoided, an existing website providing a useful service wins further support and a potential government PR disaster becomes a triumph for all concerned. Can we have more of this, please?

  6. Andy Says:

    @Gary: But there *is* an organisation that knows exactly where all the postboxes are. Can you guess who it is?

    (Hint: its name is an anagram of ‘rodnance suvrey’…)

  7. Peter W Says:

    Alerted Radio 4’s pm programme about the issue see http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/ipm/2008/11/keeping_an_eye_on_the_competit.shtml

Leave a Reply